Mythmakers Encore: John Tenniel
Key Takeaways
- Sir John Tenniel, the legendary illustrator behind Lewis Carroll's Alice books, originally viewed the Alice commission as a sideshow to his main career as a lead satirical illustrator for Punch magazine.
- Tenniel suffered a tragic fencing accident in his youth that caused him to gradually lose sight in his right eye, a secret he kept from his father to spare him worry.
- His artistic style was heavily influenced by the theater, his photographic memory, and the German Nazarene movement, which emphasized shaded outlines and narrative depth.
- Tenniel made history as the first illustrator ever to be knighted for his artistic contributions, cementing a legacy that bridged political satire and classic fantasy illustration.
- The enduring success of the Alice in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass illustrations demonstrates the immense power of a close, collaborative relationship between a writer and an artist.
Let's celebrate the contribution to fantasy of our favourite illustrators. Today we start with the grandaddy of Oxford Fantasy Illustration, Sir John Tenniel, the illustrator behind the Alice in Wonderland images. Find out about the unfortunate accident in his youth that he hid from his father, his extraordinary memory and his artistic influences. Guess who was at his retirement dinner? It is quite a fantasy dinner party moment!
00:00 Introduction: Welcome to Mythmakers and Celebrating Illustrators
01:07 John Tenniel: The Man Behind Alice's Wonderland
02:22 A Victorian Life: Family, Tragedy, and the Fencing Accident
05:49 Artistic Influences: From Theatre to the Nazarene Movement
08:37 Breaking Through: The Houses of Parliament Competition
09:24 The Craft of Victorian Illustration: From Drawing to Woodblock
10:26 Meeting Lewis Carroll: The Perfect Collaboration
11:23 Words and Images United: The Alice Books as Visual Experience
12:22 A Knighted Legacy: Sir John Tenniel's Retirement and Recognition
13:28 Enduring Impact: Tenniel's Legacy in Fantasy Illustration
For more information on the Oxford Centre for Fantasy, our writing courses, and to check out our awesome social media content visit:
Website: https://centre4fantasy.com/website
Instagram: https://centre4fantasy.com/Instagram
Facebook: https://centre4fantasy.com/Facebook
TikTok: https://centre4fantasy.com/tiktok
Frequently Asked Questions
Who illustrated the original Alice in Wonderland books?
The original illustrations for Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland and Alice Through the Looking Glass were created by Sir John Tenniel.
What was Sir John Tenniel's primary job?
While famous for his fairy tale illustrations, Tenniel's main role was as a lead political cartoonist and illustrator for the Victorian satirical magazine Punch.
Was John Tenniel the first illustrator to be knighted?
Yes, Sir John Tenniel achieved the historic distinction of becoming the very first illustrator to be made a knight for his contributions to art.
How did John Tenniel lose vision in his eye?
As a young man, Tenniel accidentally took a hit to the eye from a foil tip during a fencing match with his father, gradually losing sight in that eye over his lifetime.
1
00:00:05.305 --> 00:00:07.307
Hello and welcome to Myth Makers.
2
00:00:07.808 --> 00:00:15.416
Myth Makers is the podcast for fantasy fans and fantasy creatives brought to you by the Oxford Centre for Fantasy.
3
00:00:16.409 --> 00:00:21.752
Now, my name is Julia Golding and I'm the director of the centre and also an author.
4
00:00:22.532 --> 00:00:26.674
One thing I'm not, though, is a professional illustrator.
5
00:00:27.095 --> 00:00:32.497
I do like drawing and I have had a few maps included in books, that kind of thing.
6
00:00:32.878 --> 00:00:38.641
But I absolutely take my hat off to anybody who can illustrate art.
7
00:00:39.421 --> 00:01:03.564
And in this era when there's a lot of discussion about AI generated images and their value versus those produced by real people, I thought I would start dedicating a few of our MythMaker podcasts to the people behind some of the most famous illustrations that we all have in our imaginations to help us understand somebody's fantasy world.
8
00:01:04.545 --> 00:01:07.668
Thinking about this, I knew exactly where I wanted to start.
9
00:01:07.748 --> 00:01:14.674
I wanted to start by celebrating John Tenniel, who is associated very strongly.
10
00:01:14.754 --> 00:01:21.800
In fact, he is the original illustrator of Alice in Wonderland and Alice Through the Looking Glass.
11
00:01:23.254 --> 00:01:49.049
Now, the one thing about John Tenniel, which struck me when I began reading up about him, in fact, going down my own kind of rabbit hole following things about him, was that he himself saw the Alice Commission as somewhat of a sideshow to his main role, which was as a lead illustrator for the satirical magazine Punch.
12
00:01:49.069 --> 00:01:49.850
Yeah.
13
00:01:50.230 --> 00:01:57.016
Punch was a magazine famous in the Victorian times for its political satires.
14
00:01:58.017 --> 00:02:07.145
And if you pick up any history book about that era, you'll no doubt find elements of Punch brought in to illustrate it.
15
00:02:07.285 --> 00:02:09.427
It's become synonymous with the period.
16
00:02:10.087 --> 00:02:12.609
And he was one of the lead illustrators.
17
00:02:13.610 --> 00:02:18.673
And so his weekly life was thinking about political cartoons.
18
00:02:19.534 --> 00:02:21.035
But let's start at the very beginning.
19
00:02:22.416 --> 00:02:29.400
So he was one of a large family born at the beginning of the 19th century, and he had actually a long life.
20
00:02:29.460 --> 00:02:36.304
He died either in 1992 or 1993, because he died around his birthday, in 1914.
21
00:02:36.744 --> 00:02:37.485
So he basically...
22
00:02:39.927 --> 00:02:45.233
lived the whole Victorian period and into the Edwardian period before dying.
23
00:02:46.074 --> 00:02:57.809
His actual private life doesn't seem that tempestuous, but it is quite sad in that there's quite a lot of deaths in the family and his own wife
24
00:02:58.550 --> 00:03:04.291
whom he married in 1853, only survived two and a half years.
25
00:03:04.351 --> 00:03:05.331
She had ill health.
26
00:03:05.912 --> 00:03:07.992
So she died in 1856.
27
00:03:08.432 --> 00:03:11.713
Her name was Julia from an Italian family.
28
00:03:12.033 --> 00:03:17.674
And after that, his mother-in-law stayed with him in his house until her death and then a sister.
29
00:03:17.714 --> 00:03:23.955
So he was a man without his own family, next generation family, so living quite quietly.
30
00:03:24.015 --> 00:03:26.096
So a lot of the energy and energy
31
00:03:26.876 --> 00:03:31.680
his connections were through his work and his art, from what I can gather.
32
00:03:32.120 --> 00:03:39.205
He also does seem an incredibly kind man and desperate not to make other people suffer.
33
00:03:39.986 --> 00:03:50.233
One of the strange things in his biography that came up in a number of sources talking about him is that his father was a fencing and dance master.
34
00:03:51.294 --> 00:03:53.134
Sounds quite a Dickensian character.
35
00:03:53.795 --> 00:04:00.576
The sort of person who gave lessons in schools to teach people those social graces.
36
00:04:01.536 --> 00:04:06.277
And when he was young, he was said to have been fencing with his father, just as a friendly match.
37
00:04:06.897 --> 00:04:14.019
And the tip came off the end of his father's foil, which went into Tenniel's eye and caused some damage.
38
00:04:14.559 --> 00:04:18.720
And then increasingly over life, he lost the sight of that eye and, again, he lost the sight of that eye.
39
00:04:19.060 --> 00:04:29.549
But he never told his father because he didn't want his father to worry about him, which I think that is, sometimes it's these small things about somebody.
40
00:04:29.569 --> 00:04:38.816
It's a big event in his life, but a habit or a trait like that really says a lot about the innate kindness of someone.
41
00:04:39.497 --> 00:04:44.661
And actually, when you look at the world of Alice's drawing, so there is a satirical
42
00:04:45.802 --> 00:04:50.225
feel to it and certainly a quirkiness and a grotesqueness.
43
00:04:50.245 --> 00:04:55.748
There's also an element of is kindness the right word?
44
00:04:55.828 --> 00:05:01.651
I always feel they feel quite a welcoming world despite the fact that the characters are so outrageous.
45
00:05:02.392 --> 00:05:09.056
Anyway, so that was some of the things I learned about him as a person.
46
00:05:10.336 --> 00:05:14.019
He also had the distinction of having a photographic memory.
47
00:05:14.839 --> 00:05:24.363
And the way he got into art was he would go around sketching, creating a portfolio, which got him into the Royal College of Art.
48
00:05:24.703 --> 00:05:32.947
And these were in the era when what you did is you went and drew statues, Greek statues, that kind of thing, and showed that you were a good draftsman.
49
00:05:33.547 --> 00:05:37.909
He was very unimpressed by the education he then got at college.
50
00:05:38.530 --> 00:05:43.212
And it was other places that he drew his inspiration, notably the theatre.
51
00:05:43.272 --> 00:05:46.393
He would go and sketch, sitting, watching performances.
52
00:05:47.254 --> 00:05:48.975
He would appear in them himself.
53
00:05:49.815 --> 00:05:55.418
There's an article about him on the V&A website, the Victoria and Albert Museum website,
54
00:05:55.538 --> 00:06:04.124
when they had an exhibition of his work, which includes the absolute classic photo of him because he's in the era when photography is just happening.
55
00:06:04.484 --> 00:06:08.827
He's in a production which is a benefit performance, like a charity performance.
56
00:06:09.267 --> 00:06:21.575
And it's a kind of who's who of luminaries at the time, including Arthur Sullivan, the Gilbert and Sullivan composer, and Ellen Terry, who was the lead actress of her day.
57
00:06:22.336 --> 00:06:23.276
She was...
58
00:06:24.277 --> 00:06:24.939
the most famous.
59
00:06:24.959 --> 00:06:30.294
And he's there in the cast with his wonderful walrus moustache in the back row.
60
00:06:30.575 --> 00:06:31.458
Well worth looking at.
61
00:06:33.332 --> 00:06:52.555
So, theatre was definitely an influence, but looking through where he got his artistic influence from, many of the articles, books about him mentioned the Nazarene movement of the early 19th century.
62
00:06:52.896 --> 00:06:54.056
Now, this was new to me.
63
00:06:54.716 --> 00:06:58.036
My background is more in literature rather than in the fine arts.
64
00:06:58.597 --> 00:06:59.997
So, I hadn't really heard of this
65
00:07:01.618 --> 00:07:10.048
which was a German romantic movement of young artists who were revolting against the idea of the neoclassicism.
66
00:07:10.368 --> 00:07:14.152
They thought that was cold and lacked spirituality.
67
00:07:14.753 --> 00:07:17.336
And they lived together in an experimental community.
68
00:07:17.877 --> 00:07:19.899
They left Germany, went to Rome,
69
00:07:20.800 --> 00:07:33.931
and a group of them lived together for a few years until about 1830, where they were taking their models from medieval and early Renaissance art.
70
00:07:34.491 --> 00:07:42.818
This makes them precursors to the movements I am more familiar with, and I expect many of you are, which is the Pre-Raphaelite movement.
71
00:07:42.838 --> 00:07:43.919
It was
72
00:07:46.441 --> 00:07:51.664
the German version of this, the Nazarene movement that influenced Tenniel.
73
00:07:52.385 --> 00:07:54.466
And if you're thinking, well, what does that mean?
74
00:07:55.206 --> 00:07:58.388
Apparently, it means that you have a sort of shaded outline.
75
00:07:58.529 --> 00:08:03.792
And if you think of how the Alice illustrations are produced, you have that.
76
00:08:04.232 --> 00:08:08.575
You've got the sort of outline, but you've got the shades and the hatching to kind of give the color, the
77
00:08:09.475 --> 00:08:13.419
the sense of the character and the landscapes.
78
00:08:13.899 --> 00:08:18.683
It also leads to, and it's a good way of building up the basis of a fresco.
79
00:08:18.703 --> 00:08:36.477
There was in public buildings, there was a fashion for the old idea of frescoes, which obviously is a, you would have found in many buildings in Greece and Rome, but also in medieval periods, Antenio was part of that movement because he entered a competition
80
00:08:37.898 --> 00:08:43.364
before he was known, to design a fresco for the newly rebuilt Houses of Parliament.
81
00:08:43.924 --> 00:08:46.567
The old Houses of Parliament, or parts of them, had burnt down.
82
00:08:47.308 --> 00:08:52.933
And the building that you know today, the one with Big Ben, was built in the 1830s.
83
00:08:53.574 --> 00:08:59.420
And he entered that competition and won, and that became his sort of start in life.
84
00:08:59.840 --> 00:09:01.282
So competitions are obviously good.
85
00:09:01.722 --> 00:09:10.127
He then became an illustrator for books and his first commission in that way was the 1842 Book of British Ballads.
86
00:09:10.848 --> 00:09:14.690
He was also illustrating for people like Dickens in the magazine world.
87
00:09:15.830 --> 00:09:23.315
And it was from that that he then got the role of working for Punch, which demanded a lot of drawings each week.
88
00:09:24.523 --> 00:09:28.706
So how did they actually go about doing their art?
89
00:09:29.427 --> 00:09:34.031
Now we're used to the idea of people designing on computers and iPads and what have you.
90
00:09:34.071 --> 00:09:35.171
What was the equivalent then?
91
00:09:35.712 --> 00:09:41.456
Well, he would draw his illustrations and then it would be transferred to woodblocks.
92
00:09:42.217 --> 00:09:45.680
And one of the reasons why he got his job was he knew how to do that.
93
00:09:46.100 --> 00:09:52.285
And these wood blocks would then be, they're engraved by people who knew how to do that.
94
00:09:53.285 --> 00:09:57.469
And then they were turned into electrolyte copies for reproduction.
95
00:09:57.489 --> 00:09:58.649
That was what the publisher used.
96
00:09:58.669 --> 00:10:00.331
So there's like a three-stage process.
97
00:10:00.351 --> 00:10:01.672
You've got the drawing.
98
00:10:02.252 --> 00:10:03.993
So there's Tenniel doing his drawing.
99
00:10:04.334 --> 00:10:06.836
But he has to bear in mind that it's going to become a wood block.
100
00:10:06.856 --> 00:10:07.376
Yeah.
101
00:10:07.736 --> 00:10:10.138
So you can only use techniques that transfer to wood.
102
00:10:10.979 --> 00:10:15.623
They're engraved on the wood block and then become electrotype copies.
103
00:10:18.208 --> 00:10:20.269
So he had this long and successful career.
104
00:10:20.329 --> 00:10:25.812
And during that, he met many people in the Victorian establishment.
105
00:10:26.693 --> 00:10:28.874
And one of those people he met was Lewis Carroll.
106
00:10:29.835 --> 00:10:46.344
And so Lewis Carroll probably didn't know him from the time before Punch, as far as we can tell, but he understood that there was something, uh, particularly suited the world of the caricature cartoon that suited the zany world of Alice in Wonderland.
107
00:10:47.445 --> 00:10:53.507
And there were a number of things, I think, that drew him to Tenniel.
108
00:10:53.827 --> 00:10:57.228
One is this ability to have something that could be well-produced in a book.
109
00:10:57.248 --> 00:10:59.049
You know, he's got the craft, he's got the craft.
110
00:10:59.689 --> 00:11:01.530
But there's a sense of,
111
00:11:03.571 --> 00:11:05.812
something specific about the faces.
112
00:11:05.872 --> 00:11:12.893
He's very good at individual characters and even his settings, they're just little details which really do root it.
113
00:11:13.493 --> 00:11:22.855
And another part which is pushing the grotesque but not to the point where it becomes to act against the words.
114
00:11:23.315 --> 00:11:28.296
There's a very important relationship between the words and the illustrations in the Alice books.
115
00:11:28.957 --> 00:11:29.877
If you've looked at and
116
00:11:31.077 --> 00:11:39.742
one that reproduces the original pages, you'll see that the words fit where the illustrations are and vice versa.
117
00:11:40.043 --> 00:11:44.225
It's not a situation where you've got color plates that sort of slot into the book and could almost be anywhere.
118
00:11:44.926 --> 00:11:51.530
The words and the illustrations work together in the same way the shape poem, like the mouse's tail, has to be set in a certain way.
119
00:11:52.270 --> 00:11:54.832
So it is very much a collaboration
120
00:11:55.812 --> 00:11:58.394
Probably the words came first, it's that thing.
121
00:11:59.135 --> 00:12:09.222
The words came first, but then once they were putting it in the book, the illustrations were very much meant to enhance the experience of reading.
122
00:12:09.663 --> 00:12:11.104
So how did it come to an end?
123
00:12:11.124 --> 00:12:11.904
So after these...
124
00:12:12.725 --> 00:12:13.986
two most famous commissions.
125
00:12:14.006 --> 00:12:18.910
He also did further work for Lewis Cowell, but they are obviously his most famous ones.
126
00:12:19.610 --> 00:12:22.392
He lived a long, successful life.
127
00:12:22.633 --> 00:12:27.937
One fascinating thing about John Tenniel, which I had no idea about before I started reading up on him,
128
00:12:28.517 --> 00:12:34.242
was that he was the first illustrator to be made into a knight.
129
00:12:34.863 --> 00:12:38.165
So he ended his life as Sir John Tenniel.
130
00:12:38.366 --> 00:12:49.475
After that stage, it was quite rare for somebody in the arts to be knighted, but there was a change during the Victorian period with famous actors being knighted and the occasional author.
131
00:12:50.096 --> 00:12:54.620
But he was the first in the illustrators to be knighted for that reason.
132
00:12:55.100 --> 00:13:10.837
When he retired because of his failing eyesight, amongst other things, he had an amazing retirement banquet where on the guest list were Bram Stoker, he of Dracula, and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, he of Sherlock fame.
133
00:13:10.857 --> 00:13:11.918
So what an amazing...
134
00:13:12.699 --> 00:13:13.921
banquet.
135
00:13:13.941 --> 00:13:19.649
It was actually chaired by the then leader of the House of Commons.
136
00:13:20.070 --> 00:13:26.960
He did straddle this world between politics and literature, which makes him a very interesting figure.
137
00:13:28.015 --> 00:13:30.197
What has been his legacy?
138
00:13:30.918 --> 00:13:37.484
Well, I think his legacy is seen in later illustrators like Chris Riddell.
139
00:13:37.624 --> 00:13:44.450
The idea that you can be both a cartoonist and an illustrator seems to have a sound lineage.
140
00:13:44.990 --> 00:13:51.056
I think he also set up this idea that you could make a book
141
00:13:52.413 --> 00:13:54.774
almost like a visual experience.
142
00:13:54.855 --> 00:13:56.676
You knew exactly what it was.
143
00:13:56.756 --> 00:13:57.836
It was so distinct.
144
00:13:58.797 --> 00:14:05.061
And because it's never really gone out of fashion, why bother to re-illustrate Alice?
145
00:14:05.121 --> 00:14:18.569
And people have done, but all of us have in our minds those original images, unless you grew up on the Disney film, which I'm sorry if you did, but even the Disney film has the 10-year-old drawings underneath.
146
00:14:19.932 --> 00:14:31.132
And I think that this shows how when there's a really good, strong collaboration between an artist and the writer, as there is in this case, that this is something that no...
147
00:14:32.177 --> 00:14:34.979
commission that doesn't involve real people.
148
00:14:35.099 --> 00:14:44.867
So no sort of, it could be AI generated or just an illustrator doing drawings when they haven't read the book, which something does happen.
149
00:14:45.047 --> 00:14:48.310
You know, you often get front covers sent to you as authors where you think, have they read the book?
150
00:14:48.870 --> 00:14:58.838
When there is actually the knowledge of the material and understanding of the material, the illustrations really send it off into a much better way.
151
00:14:59.639 --> 00:15:02.041
they improve the artistic experience.
152
00:15:02.622 --> 00:15:10.789
And I think the other thing about Tenniel is that there's an understanding that fantasy can be serious, seriously funny, but also serious.
153
00:15:10.809 --> 00:15:17.014
I think the identity of the Alice books is adult.
154
00:15:17.054 --> 00:15:25.982
The philosophy of it is something which definitely you realize as you get older how clever they are.
155
00:15:26.717 --> 00:15:39.825
In fact, I've liked them more reading them as an adult than I probably did as a child because there's something very random and anarchic and unsafe about the Alice worlds, which as a child you were unsettled by.
156
00:15:39.845 --> 00:15:43.167
Whereas now as an adult, I think they're absolutely brilliant.
157
00:15:43.607 --> 00:15:43.908
So...
158
00:15:44.548 --> 00:15:48.452
I think the Tenniel drawings grow with that, a bit like Alice grows and shrinks.
159
00:15:48.692 --> 00:15:54.659
So here we are with Tenniel at the beginning of the most famous phase of Oxford fantasy.
160
00:15:55.400 --> 00:16:04.830
The artist who gave an eye equivalent for the reading experience of the Alice books.
161
00:16:05.976 --> 00:16:09.759
And it goes to show that illustrators come in all kinds of flavours.
162
00:16:10.179 --> 00:16:22.648
Here we've got a grand old man of political satire in Victorian period, able to turn his hand to these charming but challenging illustrations.
163
00:16:23.288 --> 00:16:25.650
If you have a favourite illustrator, do let us know.
164
00:16:25.950 --> 00:16:29.673
And we look to feature their work in a later episode.
165
00:16:30.894 --> 00:16:32.215
Thank you very much for listening.
166
00:16:37.640 --> 00:16:40.242
Thanks for listening to MythMakers Podcast.
167
00:16:40.963 --> 00:16:43.746
Brought to you by the Oxford Centre for Fantasy.
168
00:16:44.386 --> 00:16:48.149
Visit OxfordCentreForFantasy.org to join in the fun.
169
00:16:48.850 --> 00:16:55.776
Find out about our online courses, In Person Stays in Oxford, plus visit our shop for great gifts.
170
00:16:56.497 --> 00:17:01.862
Tell a friend and subscribe wherever you find your favourite podcasts worldwide.