The Shop Is Now Open! (All New Items!!)
Nov. 19, 2026

The Rings of Power Season 3 First Reaction and What the New Harry Potter Clip Reveals

The Rings of Power Season 3 First Reaction and What the New Harry Potter Clip Reveals
Mythmakers
The Rings of Power Season 3 First Reaction and What the New Harry Potter Clip Reveals

Key Takeaways

  • Season 3 of The Rings of Power shows a notable storytelling improvement, tying separate character arcs more cohesively around Sauron's military buildup.
  • The introduction of Jamie Campbell Bower as Celeborn brings a welcome emotional warmth and relatability to Galadriel's character.
  • While pacing and some visual design choices regarding the dwarves and certain plot echoes remain problematic, the series is steadily rising in quality.
  • A newly released clip from the upcoming Harry Potter series hints at a structural adaptation shift by featuring scenes without Harry present.
  • Reviewing the first four episodes of Rings of Power, the speaker rates the current season an 8 out of 10, showing significant progress from earlier seasons.



For more information on the Oxford Centre for Fantasy, our writing courses, and to check out our awesome social media content visit:
Website: https://centre4fantasy.com/website
Instagram: https://centre4fantasy.com/Instagram
Facebook: https://centre4fantasy.com/Facebook
TikTok: https://centre4fantasy.com/tiktok

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main improvements in Rings of Power Season 3?

Season 3 improves by tightly connecting disparate storylines—such as Numenor and Gandalf's arc—back to the central narrative of Sauron building his army.

Who plays Celeborn in Rings of Power Season 3?

Jamie Campbell Bower joins the cast of Rings of Power as Celeborn, adding a great class act and warming up Galadriel's storyline.

What does the new Harry Potter clip reveal about the upcoming series?

The clip reveals a cutaway conversation between Dumbledore and Professor McGonagall, suggesting the series may expand its perspective beyond Harry's immediate point of view.

How is Rings of Power Season 3 rated by the podcast host?

The host rates the first four episodes of Rings of Power Season 3 around an 8 out of 10, noting a major climb in quality compared to the first two seasons.

0:05 Hello and welcome to Myth Makers. Myth Makers is the podcast for fantasy fans and fantasy creatives brought to you by the Oxford Centre for Fantasy. My name is Julia Golding and I thought I would do a quick check-in and now we've got the first four episodes of The Rings of Power that have come out plus a clip from the new Harry Potter series that's arriving at Christmas. Just a couple of remarks about those two big blockbusters. So first of all, the rings of power. Now, you've probably gathered if you've been listening to this podcast that I'm not completely converted to The Rings of Power.

0:48 There's something for me that has just not quite hit. I certainly struggled with the first series, found it too random. And the second series for me was an improvement. And I'm judging this purely on storytelling. I'm not going to sit here and as a piece of ambitious storytelling. I think that Patrick McKay and John D. Payne, who are the writers and showrunners on this, I really sympathise with what they're trying to do. And I am excited about, you know, the sort of scope and the ambition of what they're doing.

1:31 And I find it encouraging that season three feels to me another improvement. So we're moving up to something which is actually I look forward to watching. I didn't feel that after the first season. But now, having watched the first four episodes within a week, I am now looking forward to the next installment of the rest of this particular season. Okay, so I'm going to talk a little bit about what I find are the positives, where I think its weaknesses lie, and where I think they might be going with it.

2:12 So, I think the big, what's really improved is that instead of this story, you know, braiding stories that go off into all sorts of different directions, Harfeet's over here and Numenor over there, this season has at its heart Sauron and all the stories now are connected to the fact that he is building his army evil ring bearers. And that is what is driving the other stories, more or less. The only exception to that is Numenov, but that is getting looped in.

2:57 And Gandalf's story, for example, is also being looped in. So it's beginning to come together, which is where I wished it had started. I the sense of connection between these stories. So you can invest in the main storyline of the history of this second age. So I think that is a big improvement. This season particularly has been fun. Watching not only in the interviews, cast interviews, you could see this coming, but watching it actually, you know... happen on the screen, is that you've got Jamie Campbell Bower join the cast as Celeborn.

3:41 And this is warming up Galadriel's character. So she's been fighting, fearing that Sauron was still out there, fighting against that, finding she was alongside him, you know, all that stuff. But the sort of personal side is, There was this flirty relationship at one point with Sauron. And clearly there is a sort of bond there in that she's almost his equal in some way, even though she's not a Maya. But she clearly is a power. And putting Celeborn back in, played by such a brilliant actor, he shows you how you should do elves. He has this coolness and a twinkle it's it's it's a class act so he arrives right at the end of that you see him briefly in a sort of flashback but he really comes in at the end and yeah that is he's a great keller born and to be honest that was has made the series for me i think makes her more interesting because there's a there's a love there and a longing that you can understand and makes them more relatable.

4:54 When of course she's this ancient elf, it's hard to relate, you know, she's so good at everything, but that part of it really warms her up too. So I think that, um, I feel happier about Galadriel in a way. So Morphid Clark, well done. You've been a good Galadriel all the way along, but I, I think this is, you know, your, your Keleborn is really helping. So, again, that's another plus point. I think one issue I have with any depiction of elves, and I suppose it might also be a little bit in Tolkien too, which is trying to depict elf culture is a bit like trying to imagine heaven.

5:37 So, you know, the dance and the sort of wafting around in long robes in woodland glades, it kind of feels a bit like a pre-Raphaelite painting. Something a bit fae. It's a real challenge, what I do. I don't know. I suppose I prefer the Rivendell with the libraries and the fires and the sense for home. Yeah, so that was just one bit where I thought, oh, this feels like watching an interpretive dance. But anyway, just that's a little bugbear. And I think that the challenge of putting a culture which is so much more than human culture is a real tricky thing to tackle.

6:24 So I do sympathize with them. Anyway, so yeah, yay. Big, big cheer for Cellebourne. And we've got Gandalf out in Rune, which is the land over to the east. He, at the moment in the first four episodes, is still unconnected to the others at this point. But he is doing some fun stuff. There was a moment which felt like it was mainly there so they could add it to the the list of CGI requests, freeing the Oliphant from the spell. It is making a point that there is this spell on that land and Gandalf has the power to break it.

7:08 I mean, I could see where it was coming from, but it was a touch random. Anyway, you can never have too many Oliphants. There is a sort of strange moment in that scene I think we might have seen the last of Tom Bombadil, potentially. But he is the... You see Gandalf getting fed up with all his riddles, but being sent out looking for a rabbit. And it turns into a moment where he encounters the secret fire and hears the voice of what I can only understand, I think, to be God. a bit like the burning bush and Moses in the desert.

7:50 It felt like that. So Inuvitar shows up. I think you might need a bit more, guys, if you're bringing that up. it kind of happened and we moved on. Maybe they didn't want to commit, but it was an intriguing moment because, of course, later on in Lord of the Rings, Gandalf says he's the servant of the secret fire. So it seems to be talking about the spiritual side of Tolkien's world. Yes, interesting to have there. But I think Gandalf already knew, having been a mire out in the West.

8:32 But anyway, it's fine for, in terms of, I'm not going to pick apart the lore. That's not what I'm here for. But in terms of storytelling, I think this should have been a crescendo, not just another scene. So turning to another set of cultures, the dwarves, I found these in the second season as my favourites, them with the relationship with Elrond in particular. I'm now finding them disappointing. And I'm wondering if it's because without a scale reference, when it's just dwarves with dwarves, the costumes seem too much like a parody, particularly the sort of big helmets and the...

9:16 Yeah, because there isn't a man-sized reference like Elrond, there's only briefly a couple of dark Black Riders. It feels like the problem you get in the Hobbit film, where everybody is given a strong silhouette to differentiate them, but they all become a bit like chess pieces or something. Yeah. Having said which, I think Durin looks great. I find him, he's a good-looking dwarf, and Deesa, she's great as well. But when you look at the background characters, I don't know, it just looks... For me, I don't like the design.

9:57 of how the dwarves are. I find it hard to take them seriously. Plus, they're being used for comedy, but yet there's a serious betrayal happening within that. And there's something about that in this season which I'm not here for. The idea that Durian and Thrain are sort of locked in this battle of succession, that's fine. But also, Thrain... There's this sort of bit, it's a bit of a, I don't want to spoil the plot too much, but there's a moment where Duren just flies off the handle very quickly and, I don't know.

10:38 I've got a problem with the dwarves. Maybe they will... I can see where I think the story's going to go in the next half because we know we're going to see a Balrog voiced by Simon Pegg. So I imagine Thrain is going to get his comeuppance. But there is, I don't know, there's something not quite right. And I think dwarves are really, really hard. You get really good dwarves like... Durin is a good dwarf in terms of the way he carries himself. And of course, Thorin in the Hobbit movies, brilliantly portrayed a serious dwarf, but also convincingly a dwarf.

11:21 So there are ways of doing it, and I'm not sure this is quite getting there for me. My particular issue is with the design of the dwarf guards in the world. because they look like animated salt and pepper pots. There you go. Sorry, it's my personal view. Okay, so looking at how they're telling the story, there is one main storyline, which is there is this orc called Marnuk who... whose loyalty is uncertain. That is an interesting character.

12:04 And it's nice to see an orc taken sort of seriously as a personality. And he ends up leading Galadriel and Arondir to Gundabad, which is a prison. The unfortunate thing in terms of storytelling, that set up is good and I like what they do with it once they're there. But the problem with it is there's too many echoes of the Peter Jackson triangle of Gollum, Sam and Frodo because Peter Jackson twists Lord of the Rings at that point to break up Frodo and Sam for dramatic effect.

12:49 and this is doing that same thing again. And the reason why it feels so reminiscent is they go to the same points again, like you can't eat lembass bread and the fact that he's bound and the sort of particular angst between Arondir and Manuk to the point that Galadriel sends Arondir away and he comes back. It's the same. It's far too close to the point And if they wanted to do that, they need to have changed some of those plot beats, moved it out because I kept thinking, I've seen this, seen this, and it was too close.

13:30 So whoever was writing that section, you could have, for example, simply just put another character in there. There's no reason why there couldn't have been a fourth character. That would have changed the balance. Somebody who didn't see it quite the same way changed what they were arguing about and not had the Limba spread reference. That was far too on the nose as an echo. So that was weak. But the actual character himself was a good one. I thought it was a shame, and this is where, if you haven't watched episode four, put your fingers in your ears and hum for about 10 seconds, that Marnock himself, his death gets lost because he's the same sort of grayish color as the other orcs.

14:22 They're all the same color, the orcs, in this sort of dingy, grey-bluey, black Gundabad, that it's hard to see him die because it's hard to distinguish him from the others. And I would have thought it would have been a good idea to give that more of a moment because he had become quite a main character energy during those episodes. And it has also... led to the problem of the red shirt equivalent in Star Trek, where I'm beginning to think, if you're not a canonical character, you're very likely to die.

15:03 I won't tell you which ones do, but there is that element where you think, oh yeah, haven't heard of you before, you're going to die, or become something else. Those two possibilities. And so I've talked about Marnuk's death being thrown away. There is another death that's thrown away. It's possible they could go back to it, though, which is in the story of Rune. It talks about the dark wizard killing off his fellow wizard, which causes Rune to become a sort of desert. Such an interesting idea, but it's sort of very briefly shown with the sort of explosion. Yeah. And as these wizards are Maya and there are only five of them, I kind of thought, oh, there could have been a bit more there.

15:49 But who knows, they might well go back to it and expand on that storyline. So I haven't mentioned Sauron yet, who of course is our major sort of linchpin character. He is Charlie Vickers. I think he plays the sort of cool, calm, cruelty extremely well. He is a sort of cat playing with an injured mouse when it comes to other people. And his cruelty definitely comes through. However, it does of course lead to it being... He's very calm. He walks everywhere.

16:31 And his emotion, his emotional range is, what's that Hermione Granger line, of a teaspoon. He's got a very sort of, he's a psychopath, of course. So I think there's a, when you are embodying ultimate evil like that, I suppose it's very hard to write something which is more nuanced. But there is this idea in Tolkien that Sauron started with good intention. And perhaps one of the things they could have done is lent more into that. But even when you think he might be merciful, he's not. So not Charlie Vickers' fault, but...

17:14 That character, you can see why you end up with an eye on top of a tower because there isn't very far for him to go emotionally because he doesn't love. He just schemes, wants power. So it's good that we've got Keleborn back. Three cheers for that. I think one of the interesting inventions that the screenwriters have made is they've introduced some things early. Well, obviously the wizards, but things like the fell beasts. And they're inventing some of their own lore. And in, I think it's episode four, could be three, they talk about the fell beasts because Sauron rides one.

18:03 And he says that the Felbeats were ruined eagles. Now, this isn't a Tolkien thing. Tolkien doesn't, that's not where they came from in Tolkien's mind. He only mentions them in the context of Battle of Pelé Northfields. There's a little bit about them. But let's say that is a possibility. They have a longer history. Yeah. The idea that you take something good and you ruin it does actually fit with the Tolkien's idea that the dark side can't actually create. It can only mar. It can only spoil. So I thought that was quite – I was fine with that.

18:45 I thought it was an interesting elaboration, particularly because you then see a rather wonderful, beautiful eagle – of it is sort of match that comes in at the end of episode four. Don't want to do too many plot spoilers, but I suppose it's not a plot spoilers that there are eagles because they are used, aren't they? It met on many occasions in Lord of the Rings and, and the Hobbit. So I would say overall, Oh, I must mention Numenor. Yeah. Numenor, I'm less interested in Numenor. Why is that?

19:27 I think it's because my heart of interest is in the middle earth rather Numenor and the family drama feels a little bit out of place, the generational drama. It feels almost like a different story, a different book. with the Farazon and Myriel and the faithful. I mean, I haven't got, I don't dislike it. And I particularly think Elrond, Elrond, Freudian slip, Elendil is marvellous. And there are some, I mean, there's some really powerful, moving bits about how you act out a resistance.

20:12 Though Isildur is not impressing me at the moment. Anarion seems to be a bit more, yeah, he seems a bit more of a leadership quality about him. But And it is lovely to see what you can do with good CGI to invent an island and a city and all of those things. So it is fun seeing that part of Numino. But I'm less interested. I don't know. Maybe other people find that the best bit. But for me, I haven't quite warmed up to that story yet. Okay, so I would say...

20:54 These first four episodes are promising. Big improvement in that they're holding together around the sort of Us Against Sauron narrative. Really good to see some love coming into Gladwell's life with a great actor carrying that. I hope the dwarves are going to dig themselves out of this particular hole I feel they're in. But yeah, it's improving. And who knows, if they carry on improving like this, it's going to be an absolutely brilliant series by the time they finish everything. So fingers crossed, because it would be great. So I would say that for me, it's got to be about an eight out of 10 series I was much more in the sort of five and six out of ten for the earlier series, but we're getting, we're climbing up the scale.

21:47 So well done, the team. I think you're, you know, you're getting there. And I love the actors. I think the, Daniel Wayman, is that the right name? Just check I've got his name right. Yeah. I think he's a wonderful Gandalf. Really, really wonderful. Okay, so just briefly, I'm going to dip into talking about Harry Potter, because there's now been a clip for how they're actually doing it. And what is noticeable from the clip, which takes place at the feast, is the first feast, is... is that they do a cutaway to Dumbledore and Professor McGonagall discussing Harry.

22:36 Now, the way the Harry Potter books work is almost always you're with Harry. Harry, you don't hear other people's conversations unless he overhears them in a dream or in a pensive or something like that. This is suggesting that the way the script is being written is that there are broadening out from Harry to include conversations that aren't in the books, but are plausible conversations, ones that you could imagine happening. There is, of course, the exception in the case of Dumbledore and McGonagall. It's right at the very beginning when Dumbledore brings the baby to his family.

23:21 There is a conversation between McGonagall, who's there as the cat, and Dumbledore. But there is an exception at the beginning. But it does seem to me that this would be one way to make sure we don't feel we're just watching a rerun of the films if this slightly different approach is taken in that other characters are given scenes without Harry being present. I mean, Harry is physically in the hall, but he's not listening in. So that's quite interesting. It could be that we just happen to see the one clip where this happens, or it could be actually a departure from...

24:02 moving further away from the books than the films did. So I'll be interested to see what they pick up there. So I am looking forward to seeing that series and just because it's always fascinating to see how things are adapted. So that would be really, really good to see that. Anyway, so I will stop there. Thank you very much for listening. And do let me know what you thought of Rings of Power. I'm very much approaching it in the, what, how much enjoyment can I get from it? Because I know there'll be those out there who won't touch it because it's not, you know, there's so much invented stuff in it.

24:46 But I'm trying to enjoy it. And that's the spirit in which I'm watching it. So anyway, thank you very much for listening. Thanks for listening to MythMakers Podcast. Brought to you by the Oxford Centre for Fantasy. Visit OxfordCentreForFantasy.org to join in the fun. Find out about our online courses, In Person Stays in Oxford, plus visit our shop for great gifts. Tell a friend and subscribe wherever you find your favourite podcasts worldwide.

Related to this Episode

Why The New Harry Potter TV Series Must Abandon Strict Book POV to Succeed

Adapting J.K. Rowling's beloved novels into a television series requires radical narrative shifts. By analyzing a newly revealed clip featuring Dumbledore and McGonagall discussing Harry away from his perspective, we explore whether expanding beyond…